Download PDF

1. Company Snapshot

1.a. Company Description

Blue Foundry Bancorp operates as a bank holding company for Blue Foundry Bank, a savings bank that offers various banking products and services for individuals and businesses.The company offers deposits; and loans, such as one-to-four family residential property, home equity, commercial real estate, multi-family, construction, commercial and industrial, and other consumer loans, as well as home equity lines of credit.As of December 31, 2021, it operated 17 full-service branch offices located in northern New Jersey.


The company was formerly known as Boiling Springs Bancorp and changed its name to Blue Foundry Bancorp in July 2019.Blue Foundry Bancorp was founded in 1939 and is based in Rutherford, New Jersey.

Show Full description

1.b. Last Insights on BLFY

Blue Foundry Bancorp's recent performance was driven by its announced all-stock merger with Fulton Financial Corporation, expanding Fulton's presence in New Jersey markets. The company's Q3 2025 earnings report showed a net loss of $1.9 million, or $0.10 per diluted common share, narrowing from a net loss of $4.0 million, or $0.19 per diluted common share, in Q3 2024. Multiple law firms, including Halper Sadeh LLC and Kahn Swick & Foti, LLC, are investigating the fairness of the sale to shareholders.

1.c. Company Highlights

2. Blue Foundry Bancorp's Q3 2025 Earnings: A Step in the Right Direction

Blue Foundry Bancorp reported a quarterly net loss of $1.9 million and a quarterly pre-provision net loss of $1.3 million, which improved compared to the prior quarter. The actual EPS came out at -$0.1, in line with estimates. Net interest income was $12.2 million, up $551,000 from the prior quarter, driven by a $693,000 increase in interest income. The net interest margin expanded by 6 basis points to 2.34%, supported by a 9 basis point increase in asset yields and a 4 basis point reduction in the cost of liability.

Publication Date: Nov -24

📋 Highlights
  • Net Loss Improved:: Quarterly net loss narrowed to $1.9M vs. prior quarter, with pre-provision net loss at $1.3M.
  • Deposit and Loan Growth:: Deposits rose $77.1M (+$77.1M), loans increased $41.9M (+$41.9M), driven by 10%+ core deposit and 17%+ commercial deposit growth.
  • Net Interest Margin Expansion:: NIM grew 6 bps to 2.34%, supported by 9 bps higher asset yields and 4 bps lower liability costs, with net interest income at $12.2M.
  • Share Repurchases and Liquidity:: Repurchased 837,000 shares at $9.09 avg., tangible book value rose to $15.14/share, with $423M borrowing capacity and $178M unencumbered securities.
  • Credit Risk and Provision:: Provision for credit loss rose to $589K due to economic forecast deterioration, nonperforming loans at 66 bps ($11.4M) vs. 38 bps ($6.3M) prior quarter.

Deposit and Loan Growth

Deposits increased by $77.1 million, and loans grew by $41.9 million, with core deposits growing by over 10% and commercial deposits by over 17%. This growth is a positive sign, indicating the company's efforts to diversify its loan portfolio and grow core deposits are paying off. As per Kelly Pecoraro, Chief Financial Officer, "the yield on average interest-earning assets grew to 4.67%, while the cost of average interest-bearing liabilities declined to 2.72%."

Capital Management and Liquidity

Tangible book value per share increased to $15.14 per share, and the company repurchased over 837,000 shares at a weighted average price of $9.09 per share. Liquidity and capital remained strong, with $423 million in borrowing capacity and an additional $178 million in unencumbered securities. The company's Price-to-Tangible Book Value can be calculated using the given P/B Ratio of 0.07 and considering the tangible book value, indicating a relatively low valuation.

Outlook and Valuation

The company anticipates the fourth quarter to be relatively flat but expects a pickup in net interest margin in 2026 due to repricing. Analysts estimate next year's revenue growth at 19.4%. With a P/B Ratio of 0.07 and a Net Interest Margin of 2.34%, the company's valuation appears reasonable. However, the reported net loss and the negative ROE of -1.17% are concerns that need to be addressed.

Credit Quality

Credit quality remained sound overall, but the company recorded a provision for credit loss of $589,000 primarily driven by deterioration in economic forecasts. Total nonperforming loans were $11.4 million or 66 basis points of total loans on September 30, up from $6.3 million or 38 basis points at the prior quarter end. This increase in nonperforming loans is a risk factor that investors should monitor.

3. NewsRoom

Card image cap

$HAREHOLDER ALERT: The M&A Class Action Firm Announces An Investigation of Blue Foundry Bancorp (NASDAQ: BLFY)

Dec -01

Card image cap

Blue Foundry Corporation Investor Alert By The Former Attorney General Of Louisiana: Kahn Swick & Foti, LLC Investigates Adequacy of Price and Process in Proposed Sale of Blue Foundry Bancorp - BLFY

Nov -24

Card image cap

Shareholder Alert: The Ademi Firm investigates whether Blue Foundry Bancorp is obtaining a Fair Price for its Public Shareholders

Nov -24

Card image cap

BLFY Merger Investigation: Halper Sadeh LLC is Investigating Whether the Sale of Blue Foundry Bancorp is Fair to Shareholders

Nov -24

Card image cap

Fulton Financial Corporation and Blue Foundry Bancorp Combining in All-Stock Merger

Nov -24

Card image cap

FULTON FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND BLUE FOUNDRY BANCORP COMBINING IN ALL-STOCK MERGER

Nov -24

Card image cap

Halper Sadeh LLC Encourages CDTX, MRSN, HOLX Shareholders to Contact the Firm to Discuss Their Rights

Nov -14

Card image cap

Blue Foundry Bancorp (BLFY) Q3 2025 Earnings Call Transcript

Oct -29

4. Business Breakdown

4.a. Revenues by Country

4.b. Revenues by Segment

5. Expected revenues mid-term growth (7.40%)

6. Segments

Banking and Related Activities

Expected Growth: 7.4%

Blue Foundry Bancorp's 7.4% growth in Banking and Related Activities is driven by increasing demand for digital banking services, strategic expansion into new markets, and a focus on commercial lending. Additionally, the company's investments in technology and operational efficiency have improved customer experience, leading to increased deposits and loan growth.

7. Detailed Products

Personal Banking

Blue Foundry Bancorp offers a range of personal banking services, including checking and savings accounts, credit cards, and personal loans.

Business Banking

The company provides business banking services, including business checking and savings accounts, credit cards, and commercial loans.

Mortgage Lending

Blue Foundry Bancorp offers mortgage lending services, including fixed-rate and adjustable-rate mortgages, refinancing options, and home equity loans.

Wealth Management

The company provides wealth management services, including investment advice, portfolio management, and retirement planning.

Digital Banking

Blue Foundry Bancorp offers digital banking services, including online banking, mobile banking, and mobile deposit.

8. Blue Foundry Bancorp's Porter Forces

Forces Ranking

Threat Of Substitutes

The threat of substitutes for Blue Foundry Bancorp is moderate, as customers have some alternatives for banking services, but the company's strong brand and customer loyalty mitigate this threat.

Bargaining Power Of Customers

The bargaining power of customers is low, as Blue Foundry Bancorp has a diverse customer base and no single customer has significant bargaining power.

Bargaining Power Of Suppliers

The bargaining power of suppliers is low, as Blue Foundry Bancorp has multiple suppliers for its operations and can negotiate favorable terms.

Threat Of New Entrants

The threat of new entrants is high, as the banking industry is attractive and new fintech companies are emerging, posing a threat to Blue Foundry Bancorp's market share.

Intensity Of Rivalry

The intensity of rivalry is high, as Blue Foundry Bancorp operates in a highly competitive banking industry with many established players, and the company must differentiate itself to maintain its market position.

9. SWOT Analysis

10. Capital Structure

10.a. Balance Sheet

10.b. Weighted Average Cost of capital

Value
Debt Weight 52.99%
Debt Cost 6.56%
Equity Weight 47.01%
Equity Cost 6.56%
WACC 6.56%
Leverage 112.73%

11. Quality Control: Blue Foundry Bancorp passed 2 out of 9 key points

12.a Historical Valuation

12.b Price/Earnings Ratio

12.c Margin Valuation

12.d Peers Valuation

Peers Group Analysis

Stock-Card
Shore Bancshares

A-Score: 6.6/10

Value: 7.4

Growth: 6.2

Quality: 6.3

Yield: 5.0

Momentum: 7.0

Volatility: 7.7

1-Year Total Return ->

Stock-Card
First Seacoast Bank

A-Score: 5.6/10

Value: 8.6

Growth: 2.0

Quality: 4.5

Yield: 0.0

Momentum: 9.0

Volatility: 9.7

1-Year Total Return ->

Stock-Card
Southern First

A-Score: 5.1/10

Value: 5.7

Growth: 5.2

Quality: 5.2

Yield: 0.0

Momentum: 8.0

Volatility: 6.3

1-Year Total Return ->

Stock-Card
Carter Bankshares

A-Score: 4.9/10

Value: 5.7

Growth: 4.3

Quality: 5.9

Yield: 0.0

Momentum: 6.0

Volatility: 7.7

1-Year Total Return ->

Stock-Card
Generations Bancorp NY

A-Score: 4.8/10

Value: 7.0

Growth: 2.3

Quality: 3.8

Yield: 0.0

Momentum: 8.0

Volatility: 8.0

1-Year Total Return ->

Stock-Card
Blue Foundry Bank

A-Score: 4.7/10

Value: 8.8

Growth: 5.1

Quality: 4.6

Yield: 0.0

Momentum: 2.5

Volatility: 7.3

1-Year Total Return ->

Peers Metrics

12.e Scoring Insights

12.f DCF BETA

Parameters

Short Term Growth

Short term Time

Long-Term Growth

WACC

Target Price

11.93$

Current Price

11.93$

Potential

-0.00%

Expected Cash-Flows